i corrected my answer in the second comment, it was a 'typo' in the first, and i think dimensions are alright in the second one
there is no net force on the COM, so, it must not be moving, if time period is different, relative positions of both the planets are different, hence, COM should move, by contradiction, time period is same
2(pi)[(R)^(3/2)] divided by sqrt[GMm]
ReplyDeletesry its sqrt[G(M+m)]
ReplyDeletetime period is same for both, follows from conservation of momentum
ReplyDeletebe more precise.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeletei corrected my answer in the second comment, it was a 'typo' in the first, and i think dimensions are alright in the second one
ReplyDeletethere is no net force on the COM, so, it must not be moving, if time period is different, relative positions of both the planets are different, hence, COM should move, by contradiction, time period is same
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteok..got it. you could have written the complete answer in the 2nd comment..
ReplyDeleteits probably right then..